

He walked up to the closet he suspected Nicky was in but his doorbell rang and it distracted him. One day, while chopping up meat, he realized Nicky was in his house, due to the piece of tape left on the front door that moved. He told the town that Aaron and Mya were with an Aunt Lisa in Minnesota. Theodore was searching the Golden Apple Amusement Park for scrap parts for his basement. Nicky's Waking Nightmare and the Neighbor's Buried Secrets He locks Aaron in the basement to keep him from dying like Diane and Mya, and becomes extra unhinged. At Diane's funeral, Theodore was inside the house and he started having a breakdown. His son got really mad and accidentally pushes his sister off the roof of the house while playing a game. Theodore waits in the hospital until she eventually dies. Sadly, they get in a vehicle accident with a pizza truck and Diane gets injured. Later, He and his wife leave to go to a store. One time Nicky came over for a sleepover and got into rooms he wasn't supposed to while looking for a glass of water and Theodore spooked him back to Aaron's room. In 1995, Theodore's son befriended the kid across the street, Nicky Roth. During this ritual, the Lucy Yi ceremony was also going on, and the Golden Apple Amusement Park burned down, causing the forest it was in to start catching on fire and the tunnels near where the rituals happened to fill with smoke and collapse. However, it didn't seem to work, due to two of them, Gordon Cleave and Dale Tapps being arrested and one losing their job not more than a day later. The Forest Protectors used it in a ritual when a storm started and gave the town bad luck. It was stolen by a society of humans in bird costumes called " Forest Protectors" before Theodore was able to give it to the puzzle master, who was going to keep it safe. It was able to give the user good luck but gave the people without it bad luck. Theodore made his own device with it, and it worked just like any of the other devices. The wallet had pieces to a secret device in it, which Ike found from Theodore's parents. After Ike's wallet was found, Theodore stole it and worked in the basement for weeks. Not long after, two detectives from Germany came to try to get Theodore arrested for the Germany accident, but they failed. Due to the lack of safety features and the work of Gordon Cleave, she fell into a tree and died. The Golden Apple Amusement Park opened, and a girl named Lucy Yi was in the front cart of the Rotten Core Roller Coaster. The Mystery of the Puzzle Master and the Grave Mistake However, Theodore got angry at Ike and told him to leave. Theodore reunited with Ike Gershowitz and they ate pizza for dinner at the Peterson's house. A little while later, the Golden Apple corporation asked him to make an amusement park for them, which he agreed to. He noticed his son's unique drawing talent and it intrigued him. Theodore set up an office in the basement and started working down there a lot. Theodore joked about taking his son's new room since it used to be his. The house they moved into belonged to Theodore's parents. The Peterson family quickly left and moved to Raven Brooks, Missouri. In 1991, Theodore's park in Germany was closed after an accident happened on a Flume Ride resulting in the death of four teenagers, who drowned. The Ferneh Welt and the Peterson family's Bad Blood Theodore was caught in rubble but managed to escape. Peterson got a demolition team to try and take down Bosco Bay to hide any evidence, but Jen found out his plan, and tried to stop him, but failed.

Jen's brother, Joe, ended up in the attraction while Theodore was testing it, and Joe died. In 1984, Theodore was working on a new attraction in Bosco Bay, which was egyptian-themed. Sometime in the late sixties to the late seventies, they mysteriously disappeared. However, the town became suspicious of his parents and what they were working on, and the parents were becoming a little unhinged. Theodore used to sometimes go to the tunnels below it with Ike.

His parents were popular meteorologists and built a Meteostation. When Theodore was a child, he always played around in his house with his best friend Ike Gershowitz.

